Mozzarella, Mozzarella, Why Dost Thou Fail Me? Part 1

I have, to date, taught over 500 people to make mozzarella in The Goat Cheese Making Class. (See Annie below stretching raw goat mozarella).  In EVERY SINGLE CLASS, I tell students that you can make mozzarella with any kind of milk, as long as it is not ULTRA pasteurized.  Among cheese makers, it is common knowledge that you cannot use ultra pasteurized milk for anything except watering your bushes outside.  It is a useless shadow of what was once milk, but has been heated to such high temperatures that everything in it is dead.  Everything.  And as if dead weren’t enough, the high heat restructures the molecules formerly known as milk so they won’t EVER form cheese.


The only kinds of milk you can use for cheese making are raw (best) and pasteurized (second best).  If you don’t have access to raw, you will buy pasteurized!  And based on what I teach, what every other cheesemaking teacher teaches and what you’ll read in every book and find on every website, chat room, board and blog, is that pasteurized milk will work!


But below is the ***disclaimer*** which caused me to carry out a study to determine which of 4 locally available pasteurized cows milks works to make mozzarella.  (Details coming up in Part 2)

***Disclaimer:  All milk that is labeled pasteurized will not work.***

In my study, I picked 4 locally available brands of pasteurized cows milk, both organic and non-organic, with sell-by dates around the same time.  One didn’t work at all.  Another one hardly worked.  The other two worked fine.

WHAT?????  If they’re labeled Pasteurized, WHY WON’T THEY ALL WORK???

Yes.  Good Question.  Why won’t they all work?

For now, I’m going to ask for your guesses.  I have hypothesized the answer, but am in the process of researching the milk companies to determine if my answer is correct.  So, I’m not telling you yet.

I want to hear from YOU.  Why do you think, if every cheese making piece of information everywhere says you can use pasteurized milk, WHY WON’T IT WORK in some cases?(OK, that’s an over exaggeration.  I haven’t read every piece of cheesemaking information everywhere.)

Comment below with your guesses.  Even if you’re not sure, still guess.  I’ll tell you more of the details in Part 2.

Thanks for playing!!

–  The Goat Cheese Lady

About The Goat Cheese Lady

I am Lindsey. At first I was a city girl. Growing up, the closest thing I had to farm animals were a cat and a cockatiel. In 2009, Herbert (my husband) and I bought our first milk goat and I instantly became an urban farmgirl, attempting to balance city and farm life..before I knew “urban homesteading” was a thing. That’s when we began The Goat Cheese Lady Farm, hence The Goat Cheese Lady blog you’re visiting now. After moving to the country in 2014, I embarked on life as a rural farmgirl. We continued teaching farm and cheesemaking classes, raising more goats and began construction on our cheese creamery. But life had other plans and in 2017, we decided that, due to financial and health issues, we had to close the farm for business. No more classes, no more creamery, a lot less milking. We went back to off farm jobs, I as an Occupational Therapist, Herbert in construction with his business, D&A Home Remodeling. At that point, I made a silent promise to myself that I would corral my entrepreneurial mind and focus on a job for a year. Well, it has been a year and I am back. Not to classes, cheese, soap or lotion, but back to writing. I love it. I’m not sure where it will lead me, but that’s where I’m starting. I’ll continue to write as The Goat Cheese Lady for now, and whatever the future holds, I’ll let you know. Our two boys are 14 and 11 and continue to be louder than my sister and I ever were. We have two dogs, Montaña and Flash, a cat, Jumpy, a flock of chickens and three goats. Yes, we still have Lucy, the goat who helped us start it all and was milked by over 1,000 people. She’s retired but still the boss. Chocolate provides enough milk for our family with some to spare for the dogs. Soccer friends, school friends, coyotes and mice are frequent visitors. There are way too many flies and every so often we see an owl. I’m glad you’re here. Sometimes you’ll laugh out loud, other times you’ll be inspired to appreciate the small things. My hope is that, over your morning cup of coffee or your afternoon work break, you’ll enjoy the antics and inspiration that are my daily life. Lindsey
This entry was posted in Cheese Making, classes, Farm Life, How To..., Recipes and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Mozzarella, Mozzarella, Why Dost Thou Fail Me? Part 1

  1. Cryssy says:

    I have no idea, but please tell me which ones worked, because those are the brands we have.

  2. Karen says:

    I think the success has to do with what temperature the milk has been pasteurized at, the higher, the less likely to make good mozzerella. I wonder if addition of Vit D could also affect it.

  3. sharon chapple says:

    sharon here from AMORE CHEESE in sydney,well yes to your first question uht milk can make cheese ,and suprising it tastes ok but no for its got know goodness at all.I only use raw or homegenised milk for my cheesemaking and have come across the same problem that some milks dont work.My answer is they add water to the milk and when they pasterise the milk they also add some other chemicial which i think is calcium chloride.If to much is used when manufacturing it the cheese splits like a sauce.I love getting your emails and would love an easy mozzarela recipe.Maybe come and visit you .cheers Sharon

    • Sharon, It’s great to hear from you! What cheeses do you make with ultrapasteurized milk? In Sydney, what are the regulations for ultrapasteurized (UHT) milk vs. pasteurized? I’m curious if milk regulations are different in Australia. It would be great to have you come visit!!! Lindsey

  4. Kathy Olsen says:

    I’ve been using Colorado Proud from King Soopers. It doesn’t act like the instructions say but when it’s time to stretch, it comes together. Why don’t they all work, my guess would be – the packaging is not properly labeled.

  5. Lori says:

    My first guess would be the difference in packaging – 2 in plastic and 2 not in plastic.

  6. Bob says:

    Maybe during the process of pasteurization the “rules” say a certain temperature must be achieved and maintained but there are no top end caps that say it cannot achieve a higher temperature – during processing the minimums are achieved and exceeded, the result is an ultra-pasteurized prodcut.

  7. Cortney says:

    One of the brands isn’t actually just pasteurized, it’s UHT pasteurized?

  8. Heather says:

    Some of the milk labeled “pasteurized” is actually “ultra-pasteurized?” Just a guess. I have no evidence to support this possibility.

  9. Cyndi says:

    Does it have something to do with fat content or how the milk is enriched after pasteurization?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s